Mushroom misinformation? Time to stop debating nomenclature and look at the evidence (part I)

Published: 24-Nov-2025

As the functional mushroom industry grows, so too does the need for scientific integrity, states the  Functional Mushroom Council

You need to be a subscriber to read this article.
Click here to find out more.

Unfortunately, a persistent myth is misleading consumers and product formulators alike: the claim that only the mushroom organism’s fruiting body, not the mycelium, has functional value. This is biologically inaccurate and scientifically unfounded. 

Dismissing the mushroom’s mycelium disregards decades of peer-reviewed science. Both the mushroom fruiting body and its mycelium are essential, metabolically active stages of the mushroom lifecycle, each producing unique and beneficial compounds. 

Debunking the plant analogy: a word from the mycological front lines

In a widely circulated comparison, some have likened the mushroom mycelium to plant roots and fruiting bodies to fruit — arguing that only the latter is worth consuming.

As Steve Farrar, founder of M2 Ingredients and one of North America’s most respected mushroom pioneers, explains: this analogy simply doesn’t hold true.

“Mushrooms belong to the Fungi kingdom. Plants belong to the Plant kingdom. The biological differences between a mushroom’s mycelium and fruiting body are minor compared with the massive distinctions between plant roots, leaves, stems and fruit,” says Farrar. 

Not yet a Subscriber?

This is a small extract of the full article which is available ONLY to premium content subscribers. Click below to get premium content on Nutraceutical Business Review.

Subscribe now Already a subscriber? Sign in here.

You may also like